[AIW] CFP: New Animism: Creativity and Critique, University of Leeds, Leeds/UK, 18-20 June 2020

AIW - Bartl bartl at american-indian-workshop.org
Fri Feb 14 11:51:53 CET 2020


Call for Papers

Symposium

New Animism: Creativity and Critique

University of Leeds, Leeds/UK

18-20 June 2020

https://animistengagements.wordpress.com/call-for-papers/

Keynote Speakers 

Tim Ingold (University of Aberdeen) 

Christopher Bracken (University of Alberta) 

 

In recent years, animism has been celebrated as a salutary alternative to
the processes of objectification, exploitation and alienation that
characterize humanity's relationship with nature in the Anthropocene.
Although colonial anthropology cast animism as a primitive, magical mode of
thinking to be superseded by religion and then science, numerous critics
across the disciplines have recuperated animism as a creative practice for
reenchanting the world. This "new animist" standpoint, associated with the
work of figures such as David Abram, Nurit Bird-David, Eduardo Kohn, Eduardo
Vivieros de Castro, Phillippe Descola and Tim Ingold, has now begun to
assume canonical form with the publication of Graham Harvey's The Handbook
of Contemporary Animism (2014). Harvey describes new animism as a relational
practice in which humans cultivate respectful relationships with other
persons, whether human or nonhuman. New animism therefore intervenes in
current debates surrounding capitalist crises, climate collapse, indigenous
lifeways and anthropogenic extinctions because it conceives of the world not
as a dualistic, hierarchical relation between ensouled-and therefore
entitled-humans and other non-souled beings and objects, but as a relational
meshwork of variously animated, ensouled, and agential persons. 

 

Yet the politics of new animism remains unclear. Does an ethics of "respect"
for more than human persons fall into the same relativist trap as liberal
multiculturalist forms of tolerance, leaving each "person" free to practice
his or her beliefs? Or does new animism call for fundamental changes to the
beliefs that currently structure our various relations to the world? What
might it mean, in practical terms, to follow the example of animists,
indigenous or otherwise? Is it possible to become an animist or is such a
desire a symptom of (post)modernist anomie, an ecological romanticization of
indigenous cultures, even a fetishization of fetishism? How do we bridge the
gap that remains between new animism as a Western academic formation and
animism as a disparate range of 'non-Western' beliefs and practices? What
forms of alliances are possible, and in whose interests might they work?
What role can animism play in building the collective power, political
consensus and economic transformation needed to mitigate environmental
disaster and its geopolitically uneven effects? 

 

This symposium sets out to explore, extend and critique new animism. We
welcome critical as well as creative, practice-led contributions. We
especially welcome proposals that grapple with any of the following
conundrums:  

 

*	Personhood and sovereignty: If "personhood" has been shown to
precipitate rather than resolve the contradictions between subjectivity and
the rights-bearing individual, then what are we to make of new animism's
injunction to redistribute personhood to other-than-human beings? Is it
possible to redistribute personhood in a way that undoes rather than affirms
notions of bodily and territorial sovereignty? What does it mean to ascribe
legal personhood to a river, and what contradictions arise when indigenous
peoples utilize the state's judicial bodies in order to protest
dispossession and protect the land? What to make of the Noongar author Kim
Scott's redefinition of sovereignty as 'empowerment through sharing'?
Furthermore, what would it mean to talk not just of a relational
epistemology, as Nurit Bird-David does, but also a relational ontology, an
opportunity to become more and other than ourselves? Can animism lead us
towards what Roberto Esposito has called the "third person", a mode of
generative impersonality and depersonalization that builds solidarity with
those human and nonhuman peoples that have never achieved full recognition
of their personhood? In short, how does animism lead us beyond
governmentality and the biopolitical "management" of life? 

 

*	Creativity, aesthetics and planetary community: In her work on
"planetarity", Gayatri Spivak speaks of "reconstellating the
responsibility-thinking of precapitalist societies into the abstractions of
the democratic structures of civil society, to use the planetary . . . to
control globalization interruptively". For Spivak, aesthetics has a crucial
role to play in this work of reconstellation, not least because it conjoins
the political imperative to think in planetary terms with the aesthetic
imperative "to enter into another's text." What role might art play in
mediating between capitalist and "precapitalist" societies and/or generating
a planetary sense of community? Elsewhere, Tim Ingold suggests that
creativity is "undergone rather than done". Instead of happening inside
people's heads, creativity comes about through an exposure to the world, by
submission not mastery. In what senses are poetry, novels, films, painting,
music and other art forms animating, rather than merely "representational",
in their various modes of poiesis or world-making? Conversely, how are such
forms animated by the world? 

 

*	Disenchantment and Reenchantment: Harry Garuba has conceived of
animist materialism within a postcolonial African context as a continual
reenchantment of a disenchanted modernity. But this argument, in taking for
granted Weber's analysis of modernity as secularization, risks eliding the
ways in which capitalism offers its own enchantments. Walter Benjamin once
argued that "one must see capitalism as a religion". And in a similar vein,
Simone Weil understood socialism as "the highest spiritual expression of
bourgeois society". How does new animism distinguish between good and bad
forms of (re)enchantment and magical thinking? Can animism and materialism
speak to one another? And to what extent do animist knowledges operate
already within purportedly non-animist epistemologies? Finally, what are we
to make of Achille Mbembe's argument in Necropolitics that  neoliberalism
has produced its own mutated forms of animist belief in technology?

 

*	Irony, Credence and Critique: If colonial anthropology saw animism
as a mistaken belief in spirits, how might we characterise new animism's
relation to such beliefs? Credence? Good faith? The suspension of disbelief?
Or what John Keats described as negative capability, the ability to remain
in "uncertainties, mysteries, doubts"? What space is left for criticality?
Do animist beliefs themselves constitute a form of critique?  What role does
humour play in animism? Does new animism take its interlocutors too
seriously, as Rane Wilerslev suggests, thereby ignoring the significance of
play and irony to animist practices? Conversely, Marxism, psychoanalysis,
deconstruction and other 'modern' forms of analysis (even science itself)
are habitually thought of as modes of scepticism, demystification, or
ideology critique. But might they have an important role to play as forms of
'magical criticism' (pace Benjamin and more recently, Christopher Bracken)?
How might new animism teach us to hold irony and belief as complementary
rather than antagonistic ways of approaching the world? 

 

Please send proposals (maximum 300 words) and short biographies for
30-minute papers to Dominic O'Key and Sam Durrant at
animistengagements at gmail.com <mailto:animistengagements at gmail.com>  by 15
March 2020.  

 

There is no registration fee, and catering will be provided across the
symposium. Unfortunately we cannot subsidize participants' travel or
accommodation costs.

 

Contact Email: animistengagements at gmail.com
<mailto:animistengagements at gmail.com>  

 

---------------------------------

Information distributed by:

American Indian Workshop (AIW)  .
<https://www.american-indian-workshop.org/>
www.american-indian-workshop.org  .  Facebook:
<https://www.facebook.com/groups/americanindianworkshop/> American Indian
Workshop  .  Linkedin:
<http://www.linkedin.com/groups/American-Indian-Workshop-4643588/about>
American Indian Workshop

***

41st American Indian Workshop, April 01 - 04, 2020

 <https://aiw41.american-indian-workshop.org/> Indigenous Shapes of Water

Department of Social and Cultural Anthropology, Faculty for the Study of
Culture, Ludwig-Maximilians-University, Munich/Germany

Email:  <mailto:aiw41 at american-indian-workshop.org>
aiw41 at american-indian-workshop.org

Registration:
<https://aiw41.american-indian-workshop.org/registration.html>
https://aiw41.american-indian-workshop.org/registration.html 

***

42nd American Indian Workshop, 2021

Department of British and American Studies, European University Cyprus,
Nicosia/Cyprus

***

43 rd American Indian Workshop, 2022

Esch-sur-Alzette/Luxembourg

***

Postings to AIW mailing list:
<mailto:members at list.american-indian-workshop.org>
members at list.american-indian-workshop.org

Attachments allowed: < 1MB 

(Please do not add further email addresses into the "TO", "CC", or "BCC"
field, this causes fatal bounce reactions. Postings by list members only)

 

To unsubscribe from the list:
<https://list.american-indian-workshop.org/listinfo/members>
https://list.american-indian-workshop.org/listinfo/members

 

Submitting your publication to the AIW publications databank:
<https://www.american-indian-workshop.org/publications.html>
https://www.american-indian-workshop.org/publications.html 

 

Vistit our webpage for further events:
<https://www.american-indian-workshop.org/events.html>
https://www.american-indian-workshop.org/events.html

 

Contact email:  <mailto:contact at american-indian-workshop.org>
contact at american-indian-workshop.org

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://list.american-indian-workshop.org/archives/members/attachments/20200214/745309ef/attachment-0001.htm>


More information about the members mailing list